Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures in the UK: A Guide for Employers
When you’re building a team in the UK, workplace issues will come up from time to time. So, what do you do when an employee raises a concern, makes a complaint, or you need to take disciplinary action?
You may already have processes for handling these situations in your home country, but the UK has its own employment laws and expectations. Knowing what’s expected can help you handle these situations fairly and avoid unnecessary problems.
In this guide, we’ll cover the key things you need to know about disciplinary and grievance procedures in the UK, based on 20+ years of experience of helping international businesses to stay compliant with UK employment law.
Goodwille. Good for business.
What Are Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures?
Disciplinary and grievance processes give employers and employees a clear way to deal with problems at work. In this section, we’ll define what each one is and how businesses use them.
What Is a Disciplinary Procedure?
The Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (Acas) defines a disciplinary procedure as:
A disciplinary procedure is a formal way for an employer to deal with an employee’s:
- ‘misconduct’ – this is unacceptable or inappropriate behaviour
- ‘capability’ – this is the ability to perform the job properly
To put that simply, a disciplinary procedure is the process an employer follows when there are concerns about an employee’s behaviour, conduct, or ability to carry out their role. It provides a way to look into the issue and decide what action (if any) should be taken.
What Is a Grievance Procedure?
Now let’s take a look at the Acas definition for a grievance procedure:
A grievance procedure is a formal way for an employee to raise a problem or complaint to their employer.
The employee can raise a grievance if:
- they feel raising it informally has not worked
- they do not want it dealt with informally
- it’s a very serious issue, for example sexual harassment or whistleblowing
Businesses use grievance procedures to give employees a clear way to raise these concerns. They also give employers a structured process for handling those concerns consistently.
Why Employers Need Both Processes
Many workplace issues can be resolved through an informal conversation between the employer and employee. However, when a concern is more serious or cannot be resolved informally, having clear disciplinary and grievance processes gives everyone a fair way to handle the situation.
There’s also a legal reason to have these processes in place. Employers are required to include information about their disciplinary and grievance procedures in an employee’s written statement of employment particulars.
Employers are also expected to follow the Acas Code of Practice, which sets out the principles for handling disciplinary and grievance matters. The Acas Code is not a law, but it can still affect the outcome of a legal claim. If a case reaches an employment tribunal, the judges will consider whether the employer followed the Code.
Understanding the Difference Between a Disciplinary and a Grievance
The main difference between a disciplinary and a grievance comes down to who is raising the concern and what the issue is about.
A disciplinary procedure is usually started by the employer when there are concerns about an employee’s conduct, behaviour or ability to do their job. A grievance procedure is started by an employee who wants to raise a concern or complaint about something affecting them at work.
Why Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures Matter
No employer wants workplace issues to become bigger than they need to be. Having clear disciplinary and grievance processes in place gives you a framework for handling difficult situations, while making sure employees understand what to expect.
Ensuring Fair and Consistent Decision-Making
Workplace issues are rarely straightforward. Different managers may handle similar situations in different ways, or decisions may be influenced by incomplete information or personal opinions.
A clear disciplinary or grievance process helps you gather the facts and give everyone involved the opportunity to be heard, so that you can make decisions based on a fair assessment of the situation.
Reducing Workplace Conflict
Many workplace problems become harder to resolve when people feel they have not been listened to or treated fairly. A grievance process gives employees a clear way to raise concerns, while disciplinary procedures help employers address issues before they escalate.
Protecting Your Business from Legal Risk
Alongside meeting your legal requirements, having clear disciplinary and grievance procedures can also help protect your business if a workplace issue eventually leads to dismissal.
If you need to dismiss an employee, you need to be able to show that you had a valid reason and acted reasonably in the circumstances. A fair process helps you demonstrate that you have:
- Been consistent
- Investigated the situation properly
- Given the employee a fair opportunity to respond
The UK Disciplinary Process Explained
The process explained below is based on the Acas Code of Practice, which sets out the minimum steps employers should follow when handling disciplinary matters at work.
Investigating the Issue
Before moving into a formal disciplinary process, it’s worth asking: can this issue be resolved informally?
Many workplace concerns can be addressed through an open conversation before they become a formal matter. This might involve:
- Having a private conversation
- Listening to their point of view
- Agreeing what needs to improve
- Providing support, such as training or a development plan, where the concern relates to performance
If the issue cannot be resolved informally, the employer should carry out a proper investigation before deciding what action to take. This should happen without unnecessary delay and should focus on establishing the facts.
Depending on the situation, the investigation may involve meeting with the employee in an “investigation meeting” before proceeding with the disciplinary meeting, or gathering relevant evidence for the formal disciplinary hearing.
Inviting the Employee to a Disciplinary Meeting
If the investigation finds that there is a disciplinary case to answer, the next step is to invite the employee to a formal disciplinary meeting.
The employee should receive this invitation in writing, with enough information to understand the concerns being raised and prepare their response. This should include details of:
- The issue being discussed, such as the alleged misconduct or performance concerns
- The possible outcome, including what action could be taken if the concerns are upheld
- Any supporting evidence, such as relevant documents or witness statements
- The time and location of the meeting
- Their right to be accompanied by a colleague or trade union representative
Employees have a legal right to be accompanied at a disciplinary meeting where the outcome could be a formal warning or another form of disciplinary action. They can choose to bring a fellow worker, a trade union representative, or an official employed by a trade union.
The meeting should take place without unnecessary delay, but the employee must be given enough time to review the information and prepare their response.
Conducting the Disciplinary Hearing
The disciplinary hearing is the opportunity for both sides to discuss the concerns, review the evidence and make sure the employee has a fair chance to respond.
During the meeting, the employer should explain the concerns and go through the evidence that has been gathered. The employee should then have the opportunity to:
- Explain their side of the situation
- Respond to any allegations
- Ask questions about the information provided
- Present their own evidence
- Call relevant witnesses, where appropriate
Both the employer and employee should make every effort to attend the meeting. If either side plans to bring witnesses, they should let the other party know in advance.
Making a Decision
After the disciplinary hearing, the employer should carefully consider the information discussed and decide what action, if any, is appropriate. The employee should then be informed of the decision in writing.
Depending on the outcome, this could include:
- No further action if the concerns are not upheld.
- A written warning, where misconduct or poor performance has been identified. The warning should explain what needs to improve, how long the warning will remain active and what could happen if there is no improvement.
- A final written warning, where the issue is more serious, or where there has not been enough improvement following an earlier warning.
- Dismissal, where the situation is serious enough to justify ending the employment.
If an employer decides to dismiss an employee, the decision should be made by someone with the appropriate authority. The employee should be told the reason for the dismissal, when their employment will end, their notice period and their right to appeal.
Providing the Right to Appeal
If an employee believes a disciplinary decision is unfair or wrong, they should have the right to appeal. This gives them the opportunity to explain why they disagree with the outcome and ask for the decision to be reviewed.
The employee should make their appeal in writing, explaining the reasons for their appeal. It should be dealt with without unnecessary delay and, where possible, by someone who has not been involved in the original decision. The employee should be told the outcome of the appeal in writing as soon as possible.
Employees also have the legal right to be accompanied at an appeal hearing by a fellow worker, trade union representative or trade union official.
Common Reasons for Employee Disciplinary Action
Disciplinary action can happen for different reasons, depending on the situation and the employer’s policies. Most of these reasons come under misconduct, gross misconduct, or poor performance.
Misconduct
Misconduct is when an employee’s behaviour or actions break workplace rules or fall below the standards expected. Some examples of this are:
- Bullying or harassment
- Refusing to follow reasonable instructions
- Unauthorised absence
- Breaking company policies
In some cases, behaviour outside of work can also lead to disciplinary action if it affects the business. For example, if an employee’s actions at a work event damage the company’s reputation. Employers should investigate the situation properly and consider the seriousness of the issue before deciding what action to take.
Poor Performance
Poor performance is when an employee is not meeting the requirements of their role.
Before starting a formal disciplinary process, employers should usually try to help the employee improve. This could include extra training, support or guidance.
Some employers use a separate capability procedure for performance issues, but this should still follow the principles of the Acas Code of Practice.
Gross Misconduct
Some issues are considered more serious because they can seriously damage the relationship of trust between an employer and employee. This is known as gross misconduct.
Examples can include theft, physical violence, serious negligence or serious refusal to follow instructions.
Gross misconduct can result in dismissal, sometimes without notice. However, employers still need to follow a fair disciplinary process by investigating the issue and giving the employee the opportunity to respond before making a decision.
The UK Grievance Process Explained
Raising a grievance can be stressful for the employee making the complaint, but it can also be difficult for the employer responding to it and, where the grievance involves another person, for the person it’s about. It’s important to handle the situation sensitively, while giving everyone involved an opportunity to be heard.
If a grievance is raised during a disciplinary process, the employer will need to consider how the two matters should be handled. In some cases, it may be appropriate to pause the disciplinary process and deal with the grievance first. If the two issues are closely connected, they may be dealt with at the same time.
Receiving and Acknowledging a Grievance
Where possible, it’s often better to talk through a workplace concern before it becomes a formal grievance. But if the issue can’t be resolved informally, the employee can raise it formally with their employer.
The grievance should be put in writing and explain what the concern is. It should usually be sent to a manager who isn’t directly involved in the issue, so that it can be considered fairly.
Investigating Employee Concerns
Once a grievance has been raised, the employer needs to understand what has happened before deciding what action to take through conducting an investigation.
Investigations should be about gathering the facts, listening to the people involved and making sure decisions are based on a complete picture of the situation. If an employer makes a decision without properly considering the circumstances, the outcome may be challenged and could increase the risk of legal action.
Holding a Grievance Meeting
The grievance meeting should happen without unnecessary delay (ideally within 5 working days), while still giving the employee enough time to prepare. The purpose of the meeting is to give the employee a chance to explain what has happened and talk through what they would like to see happen next.
Employees have a legal right to be accompanied at a grievance meeting where the complaint relates to a legal duty the employer owes them. For example, this could include concerns that the employer is not following their employment contract or has breached an employment law requirement. In these situations, the employee can bring a fellow worker, trade union representative or trade union official with them.
During the meeting, the employer should:
- Listen and ask questions to understand the situation properly
- Give the employee the opportunity to explain their side and share any relevant evidence
- Stay impartial and avoid making assumptions
- Take notes of the discussion and review any information provided
- Consider whether any further investigation is needed before making a decision
Grievance meetings can be difficult conversations, particularly when the issue is personal or has been ongoing for some time. Taking the time to listen properly and understand what’s happened can make a real difference to how well employees feel the grievance has been handled.
At the end of the meeting, the employer should summarise the main points discussed, confirm the next steps and explain when the employee can expect an outcome.
Communicating the Outcome
After the grievance meeting, the employer should review the information gathered and decide what action, if any, needs to be taken.
Sometimes more time is needed to investigate the concerns properly. If this is the case, the employer can take additional time and may need to hold a further meeting before reaching a decision.
Once a decision has been made, the outcome should be communicated to the employee in writing. The response should explain what action the employer plans to take to address the grievance and why that decision has been reached, and it should inform the employee of their right to appeal the decision as well.
Managing Appeals
If an employee is unhappy with the outcome of their grievance, they should have the opportunity to appeal the decision.
The employee should explain why they disagree with the outcome and submit their appeal in writing. The appeal should be reviewed by someone who has not been involved in the original grievance where possible. Employees also have the right to be accompanied at an appeal hearing.
Once the appeal has been considered, the employee should be informed of the outcome in writing.
Using Mediation
Mediation can be used at any stage of a grievance process. It involves an independent mediator who helps the people involved have a constructive conversation and work towards a resolution.
The mediator doesn’t take sides or decide who is right or wrong. Instead, they help everyone understand the situation and agree how they can move forward together.
Common Workplace Grievances Raised by Employees
Employee grievances can cover a wide range of issues. Some may start as smaller concerns that could be resolved informally, while others may be more serious and require a formal process. Common examples include:
Bullying and Harassment
Concerns about behaviour at work are one of the most common reasons employees raise grievances. This could be a complaint about feeling bullied, intimidated or treated inappropriately by a colleague, manager or another person at work.
Discrimination Concerns
Raising a concern about discrimination can be difficult for an employee, particularly if they feel they’ve been treated unfairly because of something personal about who they are. This could relate to a protected characteristic such as their age, disability, race, religion, sex or sexual orientation.
The Equality Act 2010 sets out the characteristics that are legally protected. If an employee believes they have experienced unfair treatment, harassment or disadvantage because of one of these characteristics, they may raise a grievance to have their concerns formally reviewed.
Pay and Benefits Disputes
Questions around pay, bonuses, benefits or employment terms can quickly become a source of frustration. An employee may raise a grievance if they believe something has not been paid correctly, a benefit has been removed unfairly or changes to their terms have not been properly explained.
Working Conditions
Sometimes, the concern is about the employee’s everyday experience at work. This could include issues with workload, working hours, workplace facilities, health and safety or changes to their role. A grievance gives the employee a formal way to explain the impact the issue is having and gives the employer a chance to address it.
Relationship Issues Within Teams
Difficult working relationships can happen in any workplace. If issues between colleagues or managers cannot be resolved through normal conversations, an employee may choose to raise a grievance.
This allows the employer to look at what has happened, understand everyone’s perspective and consider how the working relationship can move forward.
Common Mistakes Employers Make During Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures
Disciplinary and grievance processes can be difficult to manage, especially when emotions are involved. Having a clear approach helps employers handle issues fairly and avoid common mistakes like the ones we’ve covered below.
- Missing the investigation stage – Making decisions before fully understanding what has happened can lead to unfair outcomes.
- Treating employees inconsistently – Similar situations should be handled in a similar way. If employees are treated differently without a good reason, it can create concerns about fairness.
- Poor record keeping – Keeping clear notes and records helps show what steps were taken, what information was considered and why a decision was made.
- Missing appeal opportunities – Employees should have the chance to challenge a decision they believe is unfair. A proper appeal process helps make sure decisions can be reviewed.
- Not following the Acas Code – The Acas Code of Practice sets out the principles employers should follow when handling disciplinary and grievance matters. While it is not a law, failing to follow it can affect the outcome of an employment tribunal claim.
Managing Disciplinaries and Grievances as an International Employer
As an international employer, there’s more to consider when managing disciplinary and grievance matters. Employees may be based in different countries, with different employment laws, workplace expectations and approaches to resolving issues.
Understanding UK Employment Law Expectations
When managing a disciplinary or grievance matter involving UK employees, it’s important to understand the UK requirements and the processes expected by employees and tribunals.
This is especially important when more than one country is involved. For example, a UK employee might raise a grievance about a manager based overseas, or an employee in another country might raise concerns about someone working in the UK. Understanding which laws and expectations apply helps make sure the situation is handled in the right way.
Cultural Differences in Employee Relations
Different countries can have very different approaches to workplace communication, feedback and resolving disagreements. Something that’s considered a normal management approach in one country may be viewed differently by employees elsewhere.
Being aware of these differences can help international employers handle sensitive conversations more effectively and avoid misunderstandings.
How Goodwille Supports Employers with Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures
Worried about getting a disciplinary or grievance process wrong? When you’re dealing with an employee issue, it’s not always obvious what you need to do, what needs to be documented or whether you’ve followed the process correctly.
At Goodwille, we’re here to support you at every stage, working as an extension of your business and giving you the HR expertise you need, when you need it.
We offer a range of services, including:
HR Advice and Employee Relations Support
You’ll have an experienced HR team to turn to when a personnel issue comes up. We can help you understand whether a concern can be dealt with informally or needs a formal disciplinary or grievance process, advise you on the right steps to take and support you through the situation.
Disciplinary and Grievance Policy Development
You’ll have clear HR policies and procedures that set out what to do when a disciplinary or grievance matter arises. We’ll make sure they’re relevant to your business and aligned with the Acas Code of Practice, giving you full peace of mind.
Investigation and Documentation Guidance
You’ll know what needs to be investigated, what evidence you should consider and what needs to be recorded. This gives you a clear paper trail showing how the matter was handled and how you reached your decision.
Manager Training and Support
We provide training and coaching so that your managers know how to handle these situations properly, from dealing with an initial concern to managing formal meetings. They’ll understand their responsibilities, how to approach difficult conversations and when to bring HR in.
Ongoing Outsourced HR Services
Whether you need us as an HR advisor alongside your existing team or as a fully outsourced HR function, we’ll provide ongoing HR support with your UK employees and help ensure the right processes are followed at every stage.
Tell us about your business, your UK plans and where you need support, and we can help you find the right approach for your UK HR. With a multilingual team and experience supporting thousands of businesses from around the world, you’ll have people who understand both UK requirements and your country’s workplace culture.
Frequently Asked Questions
We’ve answered some of the most common questions employers have about disciplinary and grievance procedures, so you can get a clearer picture of what’s involved and what you need to consider.
Are disciplinary and grievance procedures legally required in the UK?
Yes, there are legal requirements around both disciplinary and grievance procedures.
By law, an employee’s written statement of employment particulars must include information about the employer’s disciplinary and grievance procedures:
- The grievance information should explain who the employee should contact, how they can raise a grievance and how they can appeal a decision.
- The disciplinary information should explain the rules and procedures that apply to the employee.
The law doesn’t prescribe exactly what these procedures must look like. However, employers should follow a fair procedure and the principles set out in the Acas Code of Practice when handling disciplinary and grievance matters.
This is particularly important if disciplinary action could lead to dismissal, because not following the Acas Code can increase the risk of an unfair dismissal claim.
Does an employee have the right to be accompanied to a disciplinary meeting?
Yes, in certain circumstances. An employee has a statutory right to be accompanied at a disciplinary meeting where the outcome could be a formal warning or other disciplinary action. This also applies to appeal hearings.
The companion can be a fellow worker, a trade union representative or a trade union official.
If you’re unsure whether the right to be accompanied applies to a particular meeting, allowing the employee to bring a companion is generally good practice. This can help ensure the process is fair and give the employee confidence to take part in the meeting.
What is considered gross misconduct?
Gross misconduct is when an employee does something so serious, or with such serious consequences, that it may justify dismissal. Examples can include fraud, theft, physical violence, serious negligence or serious insubordination. What counts as gross misconduct will depend on the circumstances and your organisation’s policies.
How long should a disciplinary process take?
There’s no set time limit for a disciplinary process, but ACAS’s Code of Practice states that the meeting should be arranged without “unreasonable delay”. The meeting itself will often take around 1–2 hours, depending on the circumstances. It’s also common to give the employee around 5 working days’ notice of the meeting to give them reasonable time to prepare.
Do employers have to follow ACAS guidelines?
The Acas Code of Practice isn’t legally binding, so employers aren’t automatically breaking the law if they don’t follow every part of it.
However, the Code sets out the expected standards for handling disciplinary and grievance matters fairly. If a dispute reaches an employment tribunal, the tribunal can take into account whether the employer followed the Code. If the Code has not been followed, an employment tribunal can increase or reduce an award by up to 25%.
Can an employee appeal a disciplinary decision?
Yes. An employee can appeal a disciplinary decision if they believe the decision was wrong, unfair or that the correct process wasn’t followed.
The employee should normally explain the reasons for their appeal in writing. The appeal should then be considered fairly and, where possible, by a manager who wasn’t previously involved in the case.
How can Goodwille help manage discipline and grievance procedures?
Dealing with disciplinary issues or employee grievances can be difficult, particularly when you’re unsure whether you’re following the right process. Goodwille can support you from the initial concern through to the outcome, helping you understand what steps to take, what needs to be documented and how to handle the situation fairly.
Whether you need advice on a specific employee issue or ongoing HR support, our team can work alongside you to manage disciplinary and grievance procedures with full confidence.